The verses in question, often referred to as the "Satanic Verses," were consequently abrogated (removed) from the Quranic text, following this intervention. Significance and Analysis of the Episode
Al-Tabari Volume 6, page 111, from the translation Muhammad at Mecca , chronicles the controversial "Satanic Verses" episode, where the Prophet Muhammad allegedly praised pagan deities before receiving correction from the Archangel Gabriel. While this account features a recorded confession of fabrication, it remains a focal point of debate between traditional theological interpretations, which often view it as fabricated, and historical analysis of early Islamic documentation. For more details, visit Kalamullah . The History of al-Tabari - Kalamullah.Com
: Al-Tabari utilized a preservationist approach. He recorded varied oral and written historical traditions ( riwayāt ) exactly as they were passed down, along with their chains of narrators ( isnad ). al tabari volume 6 page 111
If you can tell me the (such as the SUNY Press edition) or the particular event/year you are looking for, I can help you find the precise details from that section.
Crucially, and as al-Tabari's own annotations in Volume VI point out, , indicating that even among early Muslim scholars, its authenticity was doubted. Al-Tabari, true to his craft, included it as a variant account that was in circulation, but he left the judgment of its veracity to the reader. The verses in question, often referred to as
The text notes that while reciting Surah An-Najm (Chapter 53) near the Ka'bah, words were cast onto his tongue:
After the decisive Muslim victory at Badr, the Muslims captured approximately 70 Meccan polytheists. Page 111 records the ongoing deliberations among the Prophet Muhammad and his Companions regarding how to treat these prisoners. Key elements on this page include: For more details, visit Kalamullah
Before delving into the specifics of Volume 6 Page 111, it is essential to understand the context and background of its author. Al-Tabari was born in 838 CE in Amul, Tabaristan (present-day Iran). A polymath of his time, he excelled in various fields, including jurisprudence, theology, and, most notably, historiography. His extensive travels and erudition enabled him to compile an unparalleled historical work, drawing from a wide array of sources, including earlier histories, biographies, and official documents.
If the passage is central to your research and you lack the physical text:
Recommended next steps for you (choose one)
To understand why this text exists in Al-Tabari's volumes, it is vital to understand his methodology as a historian. 1. The "Collector" Approach